CFAES Give Today
Farm Office

Ohio State University Extension

CFAES

referendum

By: Peggy Kirk Hall, Thursday, September 24th, 2026

It’s hard to find news that doesn’t mention data centers and the controversies they’re raising across Ohio.  In the upcoming November 3 election, local residents will vote on data center issues in at least 19 Ohio communities (see this map). Several more controversies evolved into legal battles, with several making their way to the Ohio Supreme Court. The Court recently issued three decisions on data center cases.  

You might expect the cases to be against the data  center developers themselves, but that’s not so. Instead, each data center case pits citizens against their own local governments. Each involves a citizen-led “petition” that seeks to place data center issues on the local ballot. Two of the petitions would allow citizens to vote on whether to prohibit data centers in their communities. A third would create city charter provisions that would enable a recall process for removing local officials, presumably for their actions on data centers. In each of the three court cases, the local government rejected the petition and prohibited the issue from being placed on the ballot and the Ohio Supreme Court ruled against the local government’s actions. 

Here’s a summary of the three cases.

  1. Ashville Fiscal Officer must certify citizen petition on data center resolution

The Ashville Village Council in Pickaway County adopted a resolution last April that approved a “term summary” of an agreement with developer EdgeConneX for the construction of two data centers and a natural gas power plant on Ashville village property.  The resolution also stated that the project would not be subject to a previously enacted moratorium on data centers.  Additionally, the resolution included an “emergency clause” declaring that the resolution was “immediately necessary for the preservation of the public peace, health, and safety of the municipality” and stating that the Council needed to accept the term summary “as soon as possible so that this project is not unnecessarily delayed.”

A group of citizens organized in opposition to the Village resolution.  The group circulated a referendum petition that would allow Ashville voters to repeal the resolution on the November 3 ballot. After obtaining the required number of signatures, the group submitted the petition to the Village Fiscal Officer, who was to transfer the petition to the Board of Elections. The Fiscal Officer, however, did not forward the petition. The officer declared the petition invalid according to the Ashville City Charter, which stated that an emergency measure is not subject to the referendum process.

One of the citizens challenged the Village’s refusal to accept the petition by filing a “writ of mandamus” with the Ohio Supreme Court. The writ asked the Court to order the Fiscal Officer to perform her legal duty and submit the petition to the Board of Elections.

The Ohio Supreme Court agreed that the Village could, according to its charter, refuse to accept a petition against an emergency measure.  However, the Court explained that Ohio law requires an emergency resolution to contain sufficient reasons for declaring it an emergency. The language must “apprise voters of any specific reasons to declare the [resolution] to be an emergency.” After reviewing the emergency measure language in the Village’s resolution, the Court held that the language did not provide sufficient emergency reasons. The Court ordered City to proceed with certifying the petition to the Board of Elections.

The case is State ex rel. Mcnamara-Smith v. Grube, Slip Opinion No. 2026-Ohio-3035.

  1. Trenton improperly refused citizen petition that would ban data centers

In Butler County, a group of five citizens circulated a petition proposing to amend the Trenton City Charter with a provision that would prohibit the construction of data centers over 25 MW within the city.  If the petition was successful, the proposed amendment would be placed on the November 3 ballot. The group obtained 336 valid signatures on the petition.  However, Trenton refused to certify the petition, stating first that it did not have the required number of signatures and second that it could not be on the upcoming November 3 ballot but must wait until the City’s municipal election.

Trenton relied on its city charter to determine the number of required signatures for the petition.  The charter states that a petition to amend the charter must be signed by “ten per centum of the electors of the Municipality.” Trenton concluded that under the charter,  “electors” means all persons entitled to vote in Trenton.  Because there were 8,197 people registered to vote in Trenton in the last election, the city concluded that the petition should be signed by at least 10% of 8,197, or 820 persons. Since only 336 persons signed the petition, the council refused to send the petition to the board of elections. The city also argued that it could reject the petition for the November 3 general election, as the petition should go on the ballot for the next municipal election, which would be in 2027.   

The Ohio Supreme Court concluded that Trenton’s city charter conflicted with Section 14 of the Ohio Constitution, which defined electors as persons “who cast ballots” in the last election rather than all registered voters. The Court stated that when there is a conflict between the Constitution and a city charter, the Constitution prevails. Based on the Constitution, the group needed to obtain signatures from 10% of 1,277, the number of persons who voted in the last election. Because the group had exceeded that number, the Court ordered Trenton to certify the petition to the Board of Elections.

The Court secondly addressed the issue of when the petition should go onto the ballot.  Again applying the Constitution to the petition, the Court stated that the Constitution did not require Trenton to submit the proposed amendment for the November 3 general election ballot.  Instead, Article 18 of the Constitution required Trenton to place the matter on a “special election” that must take place between 60 and 120 days after the city passed an ordinance certifying that enough signatures were submitted to put the issue on the ballot.

Interestingly, the Court denied a request by the citizen group to award them attorney fees. The Court concluded that the group offered no evidence that the city council’s actions rose to the level of “dishonest purpose or moral obliquity.”

The case is State ex rel. Blankenship v. Trenton City Council, Slip Opinion No. 2026-Ohio-3406.

  1. Petition proposing a “recall” amendment in Sidney must proceed to ballot

Data center tensions in Sidney, Ohio have led to the circulation of several data center-related petitions in Shelby County.  The petition currently before the Ohio Supreme Court is regards “recalling” or removing elected city officials.  A second petition, not before the Court, would limit data center construction in Sidney. 

Upon learning that the Sidney City Charter does not contain procedures for recalling an elected local official from office, a committee of citizens organized a petition to amend the city charter with recall provisions. The committee obtained 561 signatures and submitted the petition to the Sidney City Clerk in July of 2026.

The city clerk, however, rejected the petition for failure to comply with a state law, Ohio Revised Code 731.32. That law states that “whoever seeks to propose an ordinance or measure in a municipal corporation by initiative petition or files a referendum petition against any ordinance or measure shall, before circulating such petition, file a certified copy of the proposed ordinance or measure with the city auditor or the village clerk.”

Determining that the committee did not pre-file a certified copy of the proposed amendment prior to circulating the petition as required by ORC 731.32, the city clerk rejected the petition.  The committee asked the Ohio Supreme Court to order the clerk to accept the petition.  

The Supreme Court determined that the clerk had erred by applying the pre-filing provision to the committee’s petition. The Court distinguished a petition proposing an amendment to a city charter (which is the city’s governing document) from an “initiative petition” (which initiates a new city ordinance) and a “referendum petition” (which repeals an existing city ordinance). The pre-filing requirement of ORC 731.32 applies only to initiatives and referenda and does not apply to a petition that proposes a city charter amendment, the Court concluded.

The case is State ex rel. Turner v. Barhorst, Slip Opinion No. 2026-Ohio-3439.

Lessons learned. The recent cases don’t resolve the data center conflicts in these communities, but they do illustrate the role of citizen-initiated petitions in data center policymaking at the local level.  Cities have broad powers to govern data center development within their borders, but Ohio law gives citizens an opportunity to challenge city governance and decision making through the petition process.  The cases teach us that the Ohio Constitution—not a city's charter—is the primary guideline for petitioning municipal laws. The Ohio Revised Code, Ohio city charters, and those who propose petitions must understand and comply with the constitutional guidelines.

A hard lesson the cities may have learned in these cases is that incorrect application of the laws that govern the petition process can be costly and add time and complexity to data center conflicts. That’s an outcome that, hopefully, both sides of the data center debate can agree on as undesirable.

 

Posted In: Property
Tags: data centers, petitions, referendum, cities, land use
Comments: 0
Subscribe to RSS - referendum